Prayers & Duties >> Salah (Prayer)

Question ID: 49350Country: India

Title: While offering Eid namaz behind imam, if musalli says Allah Akbar and goes into ruku after imam says Allah Akbar in second rakah (after zaid takbir), is namaz fasid?

Question: While offering Eid namaz behind imam, if musalli says Allah Akbar and goes into ruku after imam says Allah Akbar in second rakah (after zaid takbir), is namaz fasid? In daily namaz, if musalli say takbir (except takbir tahrima) behind imam, will his namaz become fasid?

Answer ID: 49350Posted on: Aug 31, 2020

Bismillah hir-Rahman nir-Rahim !

(Fatwa: 1976/H-548/TH=01/1434) Salah shall not be invalid in both the cases, rather it shall be correct without even being makrooh. And the muqtadi should say takbeer in such case in low voice, and it is sunnah.

Allah (Subhana Wa Ta'ala) knows Best

Darul Ifta,

Darul Uloom Deoband, India

Related Questions

Q. Qasr Salah 1702 views
Q. Is it permissible to take hadia money for reciting the holy Quran in tarawih salah 4847 views
Q. Our imam offered only two rakahs in Maghrib salah and after salam 4405 views
Q. I am am 22 year old student and hanfi my q is that ihav come across so many sahih hadith in witch this is proven that prophet (saw)did the rafia dain as in sahih albukhari and in a book of hanfi fiqh its written that rafia dain is authentic and none of them is mansookh(faizul bari2\225)moreover imam abu hanifa(ra)himself said that if u find any hadith to b authentic then that is my madhab(rasmul muti p4) but when i do rafia dain becos my beloved prophet(saw) did the same some aalims of my city says that dont do this it has been mansookh can u plzz give me just one sahih hadith that rafia dain is mansokh. 1979 views
Q. When I offer namaz witr in Isha namaz i use to read Almtarakaf in first rakat then liilafe quesh and then Qulhuallahoahad.but i observed that when i read these three surah my next day go better my work go smooth and everything goes in my favour most of the case and when i read any other surah then i feel next day things goes against me.Will it effect the Iman? 2090 views
Q. Qasr while returning 3972 views
Q. Is it permissible to perform salah in front of mirror? 9507 views
Q. Some of our friends say that Isha prayer time starts just one hour and 15 minuts after Maghrib prayer. Is it true as per Hanafi Maslak. In North America during Summer season and due to day light saving timing Isha goes up to 10:56(as per local prayer time tables). Most of local prayer time tables also indicates same 10:56pm for ishaa prayer. Please reply in detail what is correct timing we should follow in North America (canada) in the light of Ulma and any available hadees if possible. Your quick and positive reply will be highly appreciated. 6828 views
Q. When performing salaah in a sitting position, is it better to sit on a chair or a flat surface such as the floor? 2385 views
Q. Can we read surah Fatiha in (Qiyam) sirri salah or third or fourth rakah in other salat? 2821 views
Q. I want to ask u about surah recited in salah.i know we should recite them in manner such as first surah lahab then ikhlas,can it be recited by leaving some surahs in between like surah lahab then nas. 2.also i have urine dripping problem,so my pants get spoiled by urine ,so i am skipping my prayers pls can u give some help regarding this.what are the sins we get due to purposely leaving our salaats.can i make qada of these salats.i m a hanafi.pls reply soon. 2405 views
Q. Namaz Over Underground Septic Tank 1574 views
Q. I am praying Vitra namaz before fazer prayer it is around 5 minutes before starting time of fazar namaz,is it ok or I have to keep some more gap between viter and fazar namaz timing? 2487 views
Q. Having problem in offering salah during job 1915 views
Q. Want to clarify that the "Tasbeeh" which is performed in between every four rakayaths of Tarawih Prayers in the month of Ramadan. 4645 views

Total Questions: 9181

Faiths & Beliefs

Miscellaneous

Prayers & Duties

Social Matters

Transactions & Dealings

Title: While offering Eid namaz behind imam, if musalli says Allah Akbar and goes into ruku after imam says Allah Akbar in second rakah (after zaid takbir), is namaz fasid?

Question: While offering Eid namaz behind imam, if musalli says Allah Akbar and goes into ruku after imam says Allah Akbar in second rakah (after zaid takbir), is namaz fasid? In daily namaz, if musalli say takbir (except takbir tahrima) behind imam, will his namaz become fasid?

Related Questions