Prayers & Duties >> Salah (Prayer)

Question ID: 33415Country: Bangladesh

Title: salah behind imam saying Ya nabi salamualika

Question: In my office area all of the Imam who like to do qiyam and Ya Nabi Salamu Alaika, specially they do not like Tabligh Jamat. I do not like to follow them. Is our salah acceptable behind this Imam? And now I arrange a Jamah in my office with some of my colleagues. Did we do right or wrong?

Answer ID: 33415Posted on: Aug 30, 2020

Bismillah hir-Rahman nir-Rahim !

(Fatwa: 1227/1227/M=1432) If the Imams who do Qiyam and salam have shirkiya beliefs then salah is not right behind them, and if they do not have shirkiya beliefs, rather they are involved only in bid’ah and superstitions then by offering salah behind them one can get the reward of jama’ah. You are right to do jama’ah with your colleagues.

Allah (Subhana Wa Ta'ala) knows Best

Darul Ifta,

Darul Uloom Deoband, India

Related Questions

Q. Joining congregation 1229 views
Q. As salamu aleykum, I was wondering what Mullah Ali al-Qari says in his Sharh on Mishkat about the Hanafi position of lowering the finger when saying ''ill Allah'' in the Tashahhud. Does he say that the finger must be completely dropped onto the thigh (so that it touches the thigh) or must it slightly lowered (so that the finger is still in the air) ? Also what does other Hanafi scholars beside al-Qari say onto this matter ? Also can you tell us who the first person within the Hanafis was wo said that the finger must be raised at ''la ilaha'' and dropped at ''ill allah'' ? Was salaam 2271 views
Q. Is it valid to pray namaj after an imam who cut his beard partially but has done tauba and also appologised for the sin he committed? 1610 views
Q. I have just completed the Tarabih salat behind a Hafej Saheb. He did not demanded any money from us but we voluntarily collected some money within ourselves and handed over the same to him. He has accepted the money. I heard that taking money in any form is not allowed in Islam after reciting the Quran in tarabih. Kindly tell me what is the islamic guidance in details in this regards. 1.Should we avoid performing tarabih salat behind a hafij who ask for money or take money when given voluntarily. 2.Is it allowed to give money to a hafij who recite Quran on Tarabih on account of his recitation of Quran. 3.If we don't get a hafij who recite Quran in tarabih without taking or asking money what shouod we do then? 2067 views
Q. I would like to ask you regarding the permissibility of children (na-baligh) standing in the rows of adults in the masjid. In our masjid (in London, UK), 2 groups seem to have developed. 1 group says it is necessary for the children to stand in the rows at the back of the congregation during salaat, whereas the other says children should/can stand within the adult rows. Both groups quote different ulama to support their views. Can you please enlighten us with the BEST PRACTICE which should ideally be promoted and followed in our masjid (ie, what should we TRY to do in our masjid, regardless of whether the masallees will follow it or not)? 2482 views
Q. Can husband and wife both offer salah with jamah together 1923 views
Q. Assalaam Alaikum. My question is that if I have joined the Jamaat in Fourth Rakah in Zuhar prayer, and after offering Salaam by Imam, in which sequence will I recite the Surah other than Surah Fatiha in order to complete my prayer? 2235 views
Q. Dear Muftisab, My friend is a namaazi but he drinks beer sometimes. I want to know as to how much time he should not pray if he drinks beer. Please note, that he is not in nasha if he drinks beer as he drinks very little of the same Regards! 4050 views
Q. Qasar namaz in native place 5884 views
Q. Regarding qiblah direction while offering namaz 1046 views
Q. Dua after farz namaz jamaat should be ijtimaee or infiraadee. 11275 views
Q. Method of offering qaza salah 1969 views
Q. I am not able to bend my left hip and knee completely due to past accident,During performing salat my one leg inadverently points to kabbah in sitting position;Kildly explain me the correct way of performing namaz. 1751 views
Q. ASSLAMU ALYCUM 1. COLLECTIVE DUA AFTER SALLATT IS SUNNATH OR BEDUATH, EXPLINE WITH HADEES. 2.SHAKE HAND(MUSSAFATH) WITH ONE OR TWO HAND WHICH IS SUNNATH. 3.REALESTATE BUSSINESS (SELLINGLAND)IS ALLOWABLE. 1706 views
Q. Please may i know exact time of subah e kaazib? 5816 views

Total Questions: 9181

Faiths & Beliefs

Miscellaneous

Prayers & Duties

Social Matters

Transactions & Dealings

Title: salah behind imam saying Ya nabi salamualika

Question: In my office area all of the Imam who like to do qiyam and Ya Nabi Salamu Alaika, specially they do not like Tabligh Jamat. I do not like to follow them. Is our salah acceptable behind this Imam? And now I arrange a Jamah in my office with some of my colleagues. Did we do right or wrong?

Related Questions