Prayers & Duties >> Salah (Prayer)

Question ID: 30392Country: India

Title: Is it good to offer asr salat behind shafee imam when its not time to offer asr in hanafi? Can a hanafi offer asr salat according to shafee time?

Question: Is it good to offer asr salat behind shafee imam when its not time to offer asr in hanafi? Can a hanafi offer asr salat according to shafee time?

Answer ID: 30392Posted on: Aug 31, 2020

Bismillah hir-Rahman nir-Rahim !

(Fatwa: 376/276/L=1432)

A Hanafi follower should offer Asr salah after mislain (when the shadow of an object is double of its size) according to the Hanafi maslak. It is not right to offer Asr salah behind a Shafi'i Imam at Misl Awwal (when the shadow of an object is equal to its size).

Allah (Subhana Wa Ta'ala) knows Best

Darul Ifta,

Darul Uloom Deoband, India

Related Questions

Q. What is your opinion with regarding creating a symbol (round) like black at forehead dor doing Sajda? 429 views
Q. Please answer my questions about the women prayer. 1022 views
Q. Who is the right person for us specially our Imam. 377 views
Q. Is it permissible for Imam Sahib to make dua after fardh salah 467 views
Q. When performing salaah in a sitting position, is it better to sit on a chair or a flat surface such as the floor? 673 views
Q. I have just completed the Tarabih salat behind a Hafej Saheb. He did not demanded any money from us but we voluntarily collected some money within ourselves and handed over the same to him. He has accepted the money. I heard that taking money in any form is not allowed in Islam after reciting the Quran in tarabih. Kindly tell me what is the islamic guidance in details in this regards. 1.Should we avoid performing tarabih salat behind a hafij who ask for money or take money when given voluntarily. 2.Is it allowed to give money to a hafij who recite Quran on Tarabih on account of his recitation of Quran. 3.If we don't get a hafij who recite Quran in tarabih without taking or asking money what shouod we do then? 728 views
Q. I live in Saudi Arabia. I follow hanafi maslak. I want to ask whether i can offer namaz back of a immam who is ghair muqallid ( wahabi) , as his akayad and way of praying the namaz is totally different from muslim. Can I eat there food or it is better to avoid it. 731 views
Q. Can you help me please sometimes when wakeup after namaz fajr time so can often prayer at the time of sunset? 452 views
Q. When he sat down in-between the two sajdahs, he started thinking of something. 676 views
Q. Position of eyes during salah 669 views
Q. Is it allowed to fast (nawafil) the whole year in the state of mukim and musafir except the 5 forbidden days? 341 views
Q. My family i.e. my parents live in Aligarh (I an not married) I work in Noida/Delhi. Every week on Sunday evening I come to Delhi and live there at my Uncle's house (sage chachajaan). For the next five days I go to my workplace from my uncle's house. On Friday evening I go back to Aligarh. Distance between Aligarh and Delhi is about 120 Kms Every week when I come to Delhi I intend to go back to Aligarh on the comming Friday (after 5 days). And I keep minimum clothes/ belongings in Delhi - just sufficient for a week or two. Does "Qasar" applies to me? Please also guide what would be the case for my freinds who have the same routine but they live in a rented appartment in Delhi/ Noida. 689 views
Q. Fardh Prayer on a Vehicle/Boat/Airplane 857 views
Q. (1)I am a muslim student studying in Delhi.And my hometown is in Bihar.I go to my home during summer vacation. My question is that can i offer 2 rakats salah or normal rakats? (2)And If I come back to Delhi in Between for 3/4 days what will be number of rakats in namaz. 413 views
Q. Assalamu alaikum, We have few elderly and disabled people and also young men using chairs to pray as they cannot perform sajda. Few brothers are saying that there in no mention of praying using chairs in any hadiths and their prayers are not valid. Could you please advice. Jazakamullah khairun 672 views

Total Questions: 9181

Faiths & Beliefs

Miscellaneous

Prayers & Duties

Social Matters

Transactions & Dealings

Title: Is it good to offer asr salat behind shafee imam when its not time to offer asr in hanafi? Can a hanafi offer asr salat according to shafee time?

Question: Is it good to offer asr salat behind shafee imam when its not time to offer asr in hanafi? Can a hanafi offer asr salat according to shafee time?

Related Questions