Faiths & Beliefs >> Deviant Sects

Question ID: 894Country: United States of America

Title: Is there any difference between scholars of Imami Shias and their laymen, as Mufti Rasheed Ahmed Ludhanvi didnt make any distingtuion between them?

Question: Is there any difference between scholars of Imami Shias and their laymen, as Mufti Rasheed Ahmed Ludhanvi didnt make any distingtuion between them?

Answer ID: 894Posted on: Aug 31, 2020

Bismillah hir-Rahman nir-Rahim !

(Fatwa: 717=676/B)

The Imamia Shias are out of fold of Islam like Isna Ashari Shias. And, when their laymen also follow their Ulama then they also will be counted in the same category.

Allah (Subhana Wa Ta'ala) knows Best

Darul Ifta,

Darul Uloom Deoband, India

Related Questions

Q. I am in oman. i am a hanafi.can i offer namaz behind ibadhi community imam? pl reply at the earliest. 4480 views
Q. in reference to the question number 1694, u have told that we cannot term a muslim as kafir then what to say to those people who have written books which contain all the wrong saying for PROPHET MUHAMMAD (s.a.w). further u hav askd abt ilm-e-ghaib. then i would like to inform you that i have a video clip of the munazara between the aalim's of deoband and barelwi, in which the deobandi molvi's were not able to prove their aqeedah and the molvi's of barelwi had proved that PROPHET MUHAMMAD (S.A.W.) had ilm-e-gaib both from Quran as well as hadeeth. if you want then i can surely send you the clips. 3518 views
Q. What about Regarding Jamate Islami hind & Ahle Hadees ,is this within boundry of Islam ? 11994 views
Q. I have had regular arguments with the Bidati firqa for addressing Nabi-e-Kareem Sallallahu Alaihiwasallam by saying "YA NABI" or "YA RASOOL". When I tell them that only Allah SWT is everywhere and only Allah SWT can be addressed by "YA" they argue that even Rasool-e-Akram Sallallahu Alaihiwasallam is "Haazir & Naazir" and even he can be addressed as "YA NABI" or "YA RASOOL". When I tell them that Rasool-e-Akram Sallallahu Alaihiwasallam is in Madina and not everywhere they say I am wrong. Please provide with Hawala of authentic books and ahadith from where I can convince them on the usage of "YA" for ALLAH SWT only. 6470 views
Q. I am simple Muslim man ask everything from allah not visit on dargah for any needs. ppl are called we are Wahabis (Jamati). One of my friends Mohsin do niyaz kunde and visit dargah for prey from baba etc. Who is "Abdul wahab" and "sheikh Feiz " ? could you please clearify what is the actuall existance of Wahabis (Jamati) and that Ahlesunnah (who belief on baba to get something by prey from them) , what is the History of both firqa as both cliam they are correct. Are we follower of Abdul wahab or one of the Imam out of that 4. please give me the name of 4 Imam and to whom we are followin. Pls pls pls provide me the history of both firqa, who is doing correct in the light of Quran & Hadith. 5971 views
Q. Assalamualaikum (wa) I want know about Shia muslims and in sunni shariyah whats the fatwa for them? 6980 views
Q. Can you shed light on the ideologies of Javed Ahmed Ghamdi? 6778 views
Q. Please, throw some light on Ghair Muqallids. They are misguiding many muslims through their books. If there is any book or any literature on Ghair Muqallid ,about their belief .What are their common questions and their answers? JazakALLAH! 3751 views
Q. I belong to the hanafi mashlaq. My fathers sister has been married at reshinagar which are actually ahmadiyas. Is it permissible for me to go there or not. can I eat there or not.what is my obligation towards them? 3712 views
Q. Who is the founder of so called ahle hadith oe gair muqallid sect and when? 13100 views
Q. Which madhab/sect to follow 11713 views
Q. Is it permissible to pray behind barelwi imam? What are the main differences between deobandis and barelwis? How can I strengthen my iman? Is giving bayaah neccasary for purification of the heart? 12535 views
Q. Is Muhammad ibn Abdul-Wahhab and Salafi aqidah within Ahl Sunnah al-Jamah? 27655 views
Q. Is it allowed to meet shia peple, the ahle tasheeh, go to their home or have meal with them, what islam says about this? 6166 views
Q. Kya Bareliyo yane AhmedRAza Fazilae Barelviyo kae Manne walo kae peeche Namaz padsakte hai? 6365 views

Total Questions: 9181

Faiths & Beliefs

Miscellaneous

Prayers & Duties

Social Matters

Transactions & Dealings

Title: Is there any difference between scholars of Imami Shias and their laymen, as Mufti Rasheed Ahmed Ludhanvi didnt make any distingtuion between them?

Question: Is there any difference between scholars of Imami Shias and their laymen, as Mufti Rasheed Ahmed Ludhanvi didnt make any distingtuion between them?

Related Questions