Faiths & Beliefs >> Deviant Sects

Question ID: 9333Country: India

Title: Assalamu Alaikum Sir, One of Ulama in Kerala told me that, some Deoband Ulama said that the remembaring dog, cat, cow etc in Namaz(prayar) is better than remembaring the prophet Mohamed. please infom me the truth in this regard at your earliest. Thanking you Abdul Gafoor

Question: Assalamu Alaikum Sir, One of Ulama in Kerala told me that, some Deoband Ulama said that the remembaring dog, cat, cow etc in Namaz(prayar) is better than remembaring the prophet Mohamed. please infom me the truth in this regard at your earliest. Thanking you Abdul Gafoor

Answer ID: 9333Posted on: Sep 1, 2020

Bismillah hir-Rahman nir-Rahim !

(Fatwa: 1651/289=TL/1429)

On this matter, there is a book written by Hadhrat Maulana Sarfaraz namely: Ibaraat-e-Akabir. You should study it; your doubts shall be removed in-sha-Allah.

Allah (Subhana Wa Ta'ala) knows Best

Darul Ifta,

Darul Uloom Deoband, India

Related Questions

Q. I would like to ask about the Fatwa issued in 1320 A.H. (1900 A.D.) by 33 prominent Ulama of Makkah and Medina Shareef applied to Deobandi Ashraf Ali Thanvi, Khalil Ahmed Ambetwi, Rashid Ahmed Gangohi and Qassim Nanotvi as well. So whats your reply in context with the same that they were not kafir. More over in one of the books, Ashraf ali thanvi writes that the one who follows a kafir, or reads his books then he will also be considered as a kaafir. if you need then i will provide you the name of the book with the page number in which ashraf ali thanvi has written these words. Just tell me your views on this and i have still more questions to ask but only if you are ready enough to answer my questions. Because i think till today no one from madrasa-e-deoband has answered this question. awaiting for your reply at the earliest. 4577 views
Q. I am in oman. i am a hanafi.can i offer namaz behind ibadhi community imam? pl reply at the earliest. 4463 views
Q. Is there any difference between scholars of Imami Shias and their laymen, as Mufti Rasheed Ahmed Ludhanvi didnt make any distingtuion between them? 2267 views
Q. I know about thoughts of Mr Zakir Hussain President of Islamic Research Foundation and translation of quran his thoughts is right or wrong? 3173 views
Q. Mera Naam Mohammad Ashraf hai, I am working as a software professional I want to know about Dr. Zakir Naik (Islamic Research Foundation ka Head). I know that he is fitna. But I want to show this fatwa to my friends and relatives. 1. Dr. Zakir Naik ka Bayan sunanaa chaahiye ki nahi. 2. Vo TV per aataa hai, TV ke baare me islaam kya kahataa hai. 3. Vo Tie aur suit pahanataa hai, sariyat ne is libaas ke baare me kya kahaa hai. 4. Vo khade hokar ulte haath se paani(water) peeta hai, is baare me sariyat kya kahti hai. 5. Vo Dusare Dharam(Religion) se Islam ka muzakaraa(Comparison) kartaa hai, yaani dusare Dharam ko neecha dihkaataa hai, kya sariyat is cheez ki izaazat deti hai. 6. Vo Aurato ( [Masturaat] [Ladees] ) ke beech me bhi bayaan kartaa hai, ye sariyat ki nazar me kaisi cheez hai. 7. Vo Islam aur Sunnat per research (tahkeek) kar rahaa hai, kyaa iski izaazat hai. 8. Usaki tasveer (photo) hamesha akhbaar(news paper), magzine me aati hai, Sariyat photo ke baare me kya kahti hai. Also I will tell you 1 truth, I know 1 person (Dr. Warsi) he has done PHD in Fiqua from Al-Azhar Egypt. He told me that once he attended Zakir Naik session, Dr. Warsi told me that his brother in law was IRF volunteer; he gave 1 cheat to Dr. Warsi and told him to ask the written question to Dr. Zakir Naik. Question was ?Gurugranth me Allah ka naam kha ayaa hai.? Dr. Warsi told I got scared that question was pre-prepared, then Dr. warsi asked the same question to Dr. Zakir naik and Dr. Warsi he himself answered (he read the line from Gurugranth publicly, as Allah also given him too much knowledge), after that he asked Dr. Zakir naik that I will ask you another Question that, Dr. Warsi Asked ?Gurugranth me Allah ka naam 2nd time khaa ayaa aur kyu ayaa.? After listing this question Dr. Zakir Naik get scared and told will meet later, Dr. Warsi again answered. Then He called Dr. Warsi to his office (in Mumbai) after meeting,Dr. Zakir Naik asked to whom you follow, Dr. warsi told I am mureed of Imam Ghazali. Dr. Zakir Naik told who is Imam Ghazali. Dr. warsi told him he is your father and left his office. 9. I want to ask you he don?t follow Imam Ghazali, which maslak he is from. Please meraa jawaab(Answer) kitaab(book) ke hawaale ke saath dena. Meraa matalab hai ki jawaab ke baaju me hawaale kaa naam bhi likh denaa, mujhe public ko dikhana hai. Note: Agar iske alaawa bhi usake baare me kuch aur baat ho to aap log vo bhi likh denaa. 6286 views
Q. I know about why we follow deoband why not bareli shareef plz tell me some reason why? 4089 views
Q. List out the differences which Ahl Hadith have with majority due to which they are eviant. 8913 views
Q. Here (in Kashmir) almost 60% of all Masjids are of Baralvi type and they openly ask help from others (besides Allah) in dua and many more things. My concern is that if Namazz behind them is not valid, what should we do then, have we to say Namaaz alone? While we know Jammat is must for all Males. Kindly suggest me what should we do? 4198 views
Q. Who is the founder of so called ahle hadith oe gair muqallid sect and when? 13065 views
Q. Assalamo Alikum wr wb A Ahle Hadith scholar in Pakistan whose name is Abu Tahir Zubair Ali Za'i quite often calls Imam Muhammad the student of Imam Abu Hanifa as 'Kazzab' (Liar)and writes 'Kazzab (Liar) according to Ibn Mueen'. I want to ask, what the scholars of Hadith say about Imam Muhammad, how they rate him and did Imam Yahya bin Mueen (i think he referred to him) ever say such a thing which the above mentioned person has said. Please quote the views of Scholars of Hadith about Imam Muhammad with references and Arabic wording. I'll be indebted indeed. Allah will reward you. looking for reply. 3156 views
Q. Iis the book written by sheik ul hadis Zakariya [r.a] sahi [correct]? People say there many lies [jhoot] in that. Up to what extent is it right? Please, respond. 3234 views
Q. I have had regular arguments with the Bidati firqa for addressing Nabi-e-Kareem Sallallahu Alaihiwasallam by saying "YA NABI" or "YA RASOOL". When I tell them that only Allah SWT is everywhere and only Allah SWT can be addressed by "YA" they argue that even Rasool-e-Akram Sallallahu Alaihiwasallam is "Haazir & Naazir" and even he can be addressed as "YA NABI" or "YA RASOOL". When I tell them that Rasool-e-Akram Sallallahu Alaihiwasallam is in Madina and not everywhere they say I am wrong. Please provide with Hawala of authentic books and ahadith from where I can convince them on the usage of "YA" for ALLAH SWT only. 6447 views
Q. maulana ameen safdar okarvi ne gair muqaladeen ke aitrazat ki haqeeqat ke mauzoo par jo kuch likha hai uske bare me aap hazrat ki kya rai hai? kya ye motbar hai? 4590 views
Q. I am simple Muslim man ask everything from allah not visit on dargah for any needs. ppl are called we are Wahabis (Jamati). One of my friends Mohsin do niyaz kunde and visit dargah for prey from baba etc. Who is "Abdul wahab" and "sheikh Feiz " ? could you please clearify what is the actuall existance of Wahabis (Jamati) and that Ahlesunnah (who belief on baba to get something by prey from them) , what is the History of both firqa as both cliam they are correct. Are we follower of Abdul wahab or one of the Imam out of that 4. please give me the name of 4 Imam and to whom we are followin. Pls pls pls provide me the history of both firqa, who is doing correct in the light of Quran & Hadith. 5958 views
Q. in reference to the question number 1694, u have told that we cannot term a muslim as kafir then what to say to those people who have written books which contain all the wrong saying for PROPHET MUHAMMAD (s.a.w). further u hav askd abt ilm-e-ghaib. then i would like to inform you that i have a video clip of the munazara between the aalim's of deoband and barelwi, in which the deobandi molvi's were not able to prove their aqeedah and the molvi's of barelwi had proved that PROPHET MUHAMMAD (S.A.W.) had ilm-e-gaib both from Quran as well as hadeeth. if you want then i can surely send you the clips. 3510 views

Total Questions: 9181

Faiths & Beliefs

Miscellaneous

Prayers & Duties

Social Matters

Transactions & Dealings

Title: Assalamu Alaikum Sir, One of Ulama in Kerala told me that, some Deoband Ulama said that the remembaring dog, cat, cow etc in Namaz(prayar) is better than remembaring the prophet Mohamed. please infom me the truth in this regard at your earliest. Thanking you Abdul Gafoor

Question: Assalamu Alaikum Sir, One of Ulama in Kerala told me that, some Deoband Ulama said that the remembaring dog, cat, cow etc in Namaz(prayar) is better than remembaring the prophet Mohamed. please infom me the truth in this regard at your earliest. Thanking you Abdul Gafoor

Related Questions