Miscellaneous >> Dua (Supplications)

Question ID: 39202Country: India

Title: Suppose there are two hadith that contradict each other like saying Amen loudly or silently

Question: Suppose there are two hadith that contradict each other like saying Amen loudly or silently. In such cases what aspects does our great scholar like Imam Abu Hanifa consider?

Answer ID: 39202Posted on: Aug 30, 2020

Bismillah hir-Rahman nir-Rahim !

(Fatwa: 934/934/M=1433) It is better to say Amen silently as it is a dua and silence is best in dua as it is mentioned in the holy Quran: ادْعُواْ رَبَّكُمْ تَضَرُّعاً وَخُفْيَةً Also it is mentioned in hadith: خير الدعاء الخفي.

Allah (Subhana Wa Ta'ala) knows Best

Darul Ifta,

Darul Uloom Deoband, India

Related Questions

Q. We are 5 members in the family with masha allah good house and have a shop as well which we have rented for Rs.18000/- p.m.we earn from other halal source as well another 10,000/- p.m. on an average or even more, but there is no BARKAT in the money before the end of month nothing is left in hand with us?Why is this so? Please give us a solution to this problem. 1637 views
Q. Praying for birth of son 3581 views
Q. Can you please give me a wazifa I can read for a loved one's heart to tender. I was supposed to marry a man but he got under the wrong influence of his friends, he started to do wrong things and he said he didn't want to marry me anymore. Can you please give me a wazaif so he changes his bad ways to become a good muslimah, also he stops hanging around with his friends and his feeling grow for me just the way he felt when we first met and inshallah realises he was wrong and comes back to me and says he wants to marry me! 2284 views
Q. I would like to ask you is there any verse regarding saving from nazar, because one of my aunt has asked us to recite the last two verses of Surah Al-Qalam seven times and blow it on our child. 5296 views
Q. I get lot of sex thoughts ,sometimes iam lost thinking in them,was this haram??? 2695 views
Q. I have a daughter aged 7 who doesn't walk or talk she has poor coordination and balance, she can crawl and looks perfectly normal, her medical diagnosis is microchephaly, small under developed brain can you tell me which wazeefa to pray to try and help her overcome her difficulties? 3435 views
Q. Assalam O alaykum sahab, i am working in the gulf for past 3 years i had lended a big part of my earnings to one of my best friend, but now even the tenure for returning the money as committed is over, i am not even getting any reply or assurance from him, when i need the money very urgently. please advice. 1194 views
Q. I am giving my final exams please tell some dua and wazifah that I get pass in my exams. 1728 views
Q. Dua 2715 views
Q. We are regular in our prayers, sawm. I feel anyone have done black magic on my family (Allah knows best). 1958 views
Q. I visited an amil who is also Molvi/hakim for my wife, she was felling uneasiness and her health was breaking down very often, he said someone from family has done some jadu on her 9070 views
Q. I and my wife has taken a lot loan from bank to leave and to give a luxury life to our parents and to our kids, now we have stucked in this game of rolling money, some time situation comes we don't have single penny to full fill our childrens small demands.please do lets us know the dua or any other thing by which we can get rid of with depth.cause we are feed up of this calls from bank and need peace in our house and life, cause we both are fustrated in life and cant give attention to our children? 1430 views
Q. Please provide me any Zikar for to get rid of my family problems, any zakir to make my parents understand me any Zikar to make my wife understand me, i am in lot of tension because of my parents and my wife, i dont want to hurt my parents and wife feelings, according to my parents my sasural(in laws) have performed black Magic so that my life become hell, i love my wife very much. i dont want to loose her, so please recommend me any zikar. 1446 views
Q. I have been suffering from neurogenic pain in my lower par of body. I request u to pls tell me any dua which can help me to get rid of this pain. 1323 views
Q. How can I get lots of success in akhirah and in the world make lots of virtues and money for Islam and our family 1789 views

Total Questions: 9181

Faiths & Beliefs

Miscellaneous

Prayers & Duties

Social Matters

Transactions & Dealings

Title: Suppose there are two hadith that contradict each other like saying Amen loudly or silently

Question: Suppose there are two hadith that contradict each other like saying Amen loudly or silently. In such cases what aspects does our great scholar like Imam Abu Hanifa consider?

Related Questions