Faiths & Beliefs >> Deviant Sects

Question ID: 43045Country: India

Title: Tarawih

Question: My question is that what is the position of people who offer tarawih 8 rakah only by rejecting the ijma of Sahaba, so what we call them? Are they Muslim/Momin or out of Islam?

Answer ID: 43045Posted on: Sep 1, 2020

Bismillah hir-Rahman nir-Rahim !

(Fatwa: 47/47/M=1434) They are Ghair Muqallidin. They are not out of the fold of Islam; rather they are out of Ahl Sunnah al-Jamah.

Allah (Subhana Wa Ta'ala) knows Best

Darul Ifta,

Darul Uloom Deoband, India

Related Questions

Q. in reference to the question number 1694, u have told that we cannot term a muslim as kafir then what to say to those people who have written books which contain all the wrong saying for PROPHET MUHAMMAD (s.a.w). further u hav askd abt ilm-e-ghaib. then i would like to inform you that i have a video clip of the munazara between the aalim's of deoband and barelwi, in which the deobandi molvi's were not able to prove their aqeedah and the molvi's of barelwi had proved that PROPHET MUHAMMAD (S.A.W.) had ilm-e-gaib both from Quran as well as hadeeth. if you want then i can surely send you the clips. 3518 views
Q. List out the differences which Ahl Hadith have with majority due to which they are eviant. 8925 views
Q. Is it permissible to pray behind barelwi imam? What are the main differences between deobandis and barelwis? How can I strengthen my iman? Is giving bayaah neccasary for purification of the heart? 12535 views
Q. sir nikah with shea is allowed or not ???i have read your nikah book in english there is written that nikah is not permissable with shea but in (nikah hidaya) there is written that nikah with ahl-ul-kitab is sahih.are not shea ahl-ul-kitab??and also what about yahoodi ???please explain it for me thanks! 4303 views
Q. Can you shed light on the ideologies of Javed Ahmed Ghamdi? 6778 views
Q. Kya Bareliyo yane AhmedRAza Fazilae Barelviyo kae Manne walo kae peeche Namaz padsakte hai? 6365 views
Q. I am khaleel 23 year old,And i want to know that what should be our Aqeeda about the Barelvees,because i have seen them criticising Deoband seminary in their Books&in their speeches.They write very Wrong about Deoband Ulama.And they call NAJADI TO DEOBAND ULAMA.And i want to know what is NAJAD.And also What should be our Aqeeda about JAMAAT-E-ISLAMI HIND. 5148 views
Q. Which madhab/sect to follow 11712 views
Q. Who are the wahabis? Whats the difference between wahabis and deobandis? Has any of our great scholars like hazrat moulana rashid ahmed gangohi nawarallahu marqadahu said that wahabis are good people? Are deobandis also wahabis? 8570 views
Q. This is true that Rashid Ahmad Gangohe said, Crow is Halal. pls reply. 8218 views
Q. as salaamu alaikum mufti sahab . could u plz clarify me a doubt. people near my house go to dargha and bow their heads there and do nyaaz and other things and they call themselves ehal e sunnat my question to u is that is this right according to the islaam and other thing is that when u say ehal e sunnat do u refer to these people or just normal muslims (other than shias). 2452 views
Q. Assalamo Alikum wr wb A Ahle Hadith scholar in Pakistan whose name is Abu Tahir Zubair Ali Za'i quite often calls Imam Muhammad the student of Imam Abu Hanifa as 'Kazzab' (Liar)and writes 'Kazzab (Liar) according to Ibn Mueen'. I want to ask, what the scholars of Hadith say about Imam Muhammad, how they rate him and did Imam Yahya bin Mueen (i think he referred to him) ever say such a thing which the above mentioned person has said. Please quote the views of Scholars of Hadith about Imam Muhammad with references and Arabic wording. I'll be indebted indeed. Allah will reward you. looking for reply. 3165 views
Q. I have had regular arguments with the Bidati firqa for addressing Nabi-e-Kareem Sallallahu Alaihiwasallam by saying "YA NABI" or "YA RASOOL". When I tell them that only Allah SWT is everywhere and only Allah SWT can be addressed by "YA" they argue that even Rasool-e-Akram Sallallahu Alaihiwasallam is "Haazir & Naazir" and even he can be addressed as "YA NABI" or "YA RASOOL". When I tell them that Rasool-e-Akram Sallallahu Alaihiwasallam is in Madina and not everywhere they say I am wrong. Please provide with Hawala of authentic books and ahadith from where I can convince them on the usage of "YA" for ALLAH SWT only. 6469 views
Q. Today in our local masjid there was an issue raised by the imam, who is from a barelwi thought of school... he was arguing that "Every person performing namaz behind him should sit during the iqamat & should only stand up when 'haiyya-lassalah' is called." is it correct...? is there any hadis regarding this. If not is there any proof that i can show him, that will help me correct him...? thats because he was challenging everyone to get him any proof that one need not sit during iqamat.... 3090 views
Q. I belong to the hanafi mashlaq. My fathers sister has been married at reshinagar which are actually ahmadiyas. Is it permissible for me to go there or not. can I eat there or not.what is my obligation towards them? 3712 views

Total Questions: 9181

Faiths & Beliefs

Miscellaneous

Prayers & Duties

Social Matters

Transactions & Dealings

Title: Tarawih

Question: My question is that what is the position of people who offer tarawih 8 rakah only by rejecting the ijma of Sahaba, so what we call them? Are they Muslim/Momin or out of Islam?

Related Questions